Revolutionizing · Modernizing · Simplifying
Food & Drink

Estes Park's 1909 Church Is Now a DIY Chocolate Factory

The Stanley Chocolate Factory at 157 W. Elkhorn opened Nov. 28, 2025, inside Estes Park's first church, where you now build your own candy bars under a chocolatier.
By Derek Schulze · November 14, 2026
Estes Park's 1909 Church Is Now a DIY Chocolate Factory

1909. Estes Park. Volunteers are hammering together a little wooden church on Elkhorn Avenue, $4,000 in materials on a lot that cost them six hundred bucks. Same year, just up the hill, F.O. Stanley is finishing the Stanley Hotel. The one that later scared the daylights out of Stephen King and became the Overlook in "The Shining."

Photo: denvergazette.com
Photo: denvergazette.com

So two buildings go up the same year. One becomes world famous. The other quietly serves as the Presbyterian Church of Estes Park, later the Presbyterian Community Church of the Rockies, gets additions in 1929 and 1955, and then in 1982 somebody turns it into a little shopping mall called the Old Church Shops.

Here is where it gets good.

Photo: whatnow.com
Photo: whatnow.com

A $9 million chocolate obsession

Developer John Cullen bought the property in 2022. And Cullen is not a stranger to the name Stanley. He owns the Stanley name all over Estes Park, including that 1909 hotel. So he gets this roughly 125-year-old church and he does not flip it or slap a coat of paint on it. He spends four years and more than $9 million turning it into a do-it-yourself chocolate factory.

Yeah. You read that right.

The Stanley Chocolate Factory opened Nov. 28, 2025, at 157 W. Elkhorn Avenue, right on the main drag in downtown Estes Park. And the whole concept is that you make your own gourmet candy bars. Not watch somebody do it behind glass. You, in a temperature-controlled kitchen, working under an actual chocolatier, building your own bar.

Cullen did his homework on this too. The man researched the global chocolate-tourism industry and took a tour in Belgium before he launched. Belgium. For chocolate research. (Honestly that is a work trip I could get behind, and Hayley would never let me hear the end of it.)

"Rocky Mountain Chocolate Factory" by TheMuuj is licensed under CC BY-SA 2.0.
"Rocky Mountain Chocolate Factory" by TheMuuj is licensed under CC BY-SA 2.0.

The merry-go-round in the church

Now this is the part people miss when they just hear "chocolate shop."

The old church got a brand new addition. A 6,500-square-foot hexagon-shaped pavilion. And inside that pavilion sits an antique French merry-go-round. A full carousel. In a church. That is now a candy factory.

MOA Architecture led the adaptive-reuse design, which is the fancy term for taking an old building and giving it a completely new life without bulldozing the soul out of it. And they did it right. You have got the make-your-own kitchen, a tasting room, retail space, a whiskey vault (so the adults have a reason to behave), and two rooftop patios with panoramic mountain views.

So picture the Front Range family trip. Kids making candy bars and riding a carousel downstairs. You on the rooftop with a view of the Rockies and something from the whiskey vault. That is a pretty tough afternoon to beat on the way in or out of Rocky Mountain National Park.

"He saved this building"

Not everybody loves a developer rolling into a mountain town. But listen to the locals on this one.

Longtime resident Ty Ricker told the Denver Gazette's Seth Boster, who profiled the place on Nov. 11, 2026, that Cullen "saved this building." Ricker called it the showcase of downtown Estes Park. That is coming from somebody who actually lives there, not a press release.

And here is the thing. A wooden church from 1909 does not survive on its own. You either pour millions into it or you lose it. Cullen chose the millions.

The real estate twist

Now, I would not be doing my job if I did not point out the deal underneath all of this, because it is a wild one.

After Cullen spent four years and north of nine million restoring the place, he sold the building. For

4.875 million. The buyer is Tebo Estes LLC, owned by Boulder developer Stephen Tebo, and the deal was recorded April 14, 2026.

But (and this is the clever part) Cullen kept a quarter-century leaseback on the business. So he sells the real estate for almost twenty-five million dollars and then leases it right back for 25 years to keep running the chocolate factory. He cashes out on the building and keeps the operation. That is a move.

For regular people watching the market, that kind of sale-leaseback is a reminder that the real money in a destination property is sometimes the dirt and the walls, not just the thing happening inside them. Same reason a well-located Estes or Front Range property with a story attached holds value when the trendy stuff fades. Something worth remembering if you are ever weighing a place with history baked into it.

Worth your attention because

Estes Park has always been the gateway to the national park. People blow through it on the way to the trailheads. But this gives Front Range families a reason to actually stop downtown and stay a while.

A church built by volunteers in 1909. The same year as the hotel that inspired "The Shining." Four years and nine million in restoration. A French carousel, a whiskey vault, two rooftops, and you making your own candy bar under a chocolatier.

That is a weird, wonderful, only-in-Colorado combination. And it is open right now at 157 W. Elkhorn. The number is (970) 586-1617 if you want to plan it out.

Buckle up and bring the kids. This one is a proper Radically Colorado adventure.

Home·Our Listings·News·About·Privacy·Terms