Revolutionizing · Modernizing · Simplifying
Food & Drink

Two Denver Bartender Projects Just Made Eater's Best-in-America List

Eater researched 44 cities and only 20 got winners. Denver landed two: Rougarou in Five Points and Peach Crease Club in RiNo, both built by local bar vets.
By Derek Schulze · November 13, 2026
Two Denver Bartender Projects Just Made Eater's Best-in-America List

A shapeshifting swamp monster from the Louisiana bayou now has a permanent address in Five Points. It is 2844 Welton Street, and on Nov. 12, 2026, Eater told the rest of the country what people here already figured out last year.

Photo: westword.com
Photo: westword.com

So here is what happened. Westword's Antony Bruno reported that Eater's annual awards named one Denver restaurant and one Denver bar among the best in the entire country. And this is the part people miss about why that matters. Eater researched restaurants and bars across 44 cities. Only 20 of those cities actually produced a winner. The final list was 55 establishments total. Denver got two of them. That is not a participation trophy.

"17th Street, Denver, Colorado" by Ken Lund is licensed under CC BY-SA 2.0.
"17th Street, Denver, Colorado" by Ken Lund is licensed under CC BY-SA 2.0.

Rougarou, and the thing about that building

Rougarou is the Southern and Cajun spot that made Eater's list of the 15 Best New Restaurants of the Year. The name, if you were wondering, refers to a shapeshifting creature of the Louisiana bayou. Fitting, because the building it lives in has done plenty of shapeshifting of its own.

That address on Welton used to be a barbershop. Then it was Dunbar Kitchen and Tap House. Then it was Moods, Beats and Potions. Now it is a 68-seat restaurant that opened Aug. 21, 2025, and the eligibility window for these awards ran from August 2025 through September 2026, so Rougarou basically snuck in at the front of the line and still beat out the whole country.

Here is the crew behind it. Rougarou comes from the Yacht Club founders, Mary Allison Wright and McLain Hedges, with Wright's brother John David Wright running the kitchen as executive chef. A family operation, which I always respect. And they did not just win the Eater nod. When the Colorado Michelin list dropped in September 2026, Rougarou picked up a Bib Gourmand too. So this is not a one-critic fluke.

The menu is where it gets fun. We are talking hot-and-sour catfish, a dish literally called "chicken on a stick" (that one is an homage to an Oxford, Mississippi staple), a blue cheese tart, a muffaletta martini, and a cocktail named the Champagne Killer. There is a backyard for live music too. I mean, a Cajun restaurant with a backyard and live music on Welton Street. That is a Tuesday I can get behind.

"17th Street, Denver, Colorado" by Ken Lund is licensed under CC BY-SA 2.0.
"17th Street, Denver, Colorado" by Ken Lund is licensed under CC BY-SA 2.0.

Peach Crease Club, the vinyl bar next to Mission Ballroom

The bar winner is Peach Crease Club over in RiNo, and this one is a different animal entirely. It sits at 4180 Wynkoop Street, Suite 130, right next to Mission Ballroom, and it officially opened Nov. 28, 2025. So if you have ever stood outside Mission Ballroom before a show wondering where to grab a drink that is not a parking-lot beer, the answer has been right there the whole time.

Peach Crease Club is a 1970s-inspired vinyl listening lounge with a 12-seat bar. Twelve seats. That is the kind of number that tells you to go early or go home. It is the first joint project from husband-and-wife bar veterans Alex Jump, formerly of Death and Co., and Stuart Jensen, who co-owns Curio Bar and Roger's Liquid Oasis. These are not newcomers. These are people who have been building Denver's bar scene for years, finally putting their names on the door together.

And here is the clever part. The signature cocktails are named after the dishes that inspired them. So you get a Fattoush, a Carrot Cake, a Borscht, a Banana Bread. Drinks start around

6. Punch magazine singled out the savory-leaning menu specifically, name-checking the fattoush martini and the kik alicha. A cocktail named after an Ethiopian split-pea stew. Honestly, that is the most Denver-in-2026 sentence I have written all week.

The connective tissue

Here is what ties this whole thing together and why it is worth your attention. Both of these places came out of the same world. Local bartenders and bar founders who cut their teeth here, stuck around, and built something instead of leaving for the coasts. Wright and Hedges with the Yacht Club lineage. Jump and Jensen with Death and Co. and Curio behind them. This is not outside money parachuting in. This is Denver talent betting on Denver neighborhoods.

And the neighborhoods matter. Welton Street in Five Points has been grinding through its comeback for a while now, one historic building at a time, and a Michelin-recognized Cajun spot in an old barbershop is exactly the kind of thing that tells you where that corridor is headed. RiNo near Mission Ballroom keeps layering in reasons to show up before the concert and stick around after. Both are the sort of signals that, if you watch the Front Range market the way Hayley and I do, you learn to read. Great food and drink does not follow rooftops. It leads them.

So the move is simple. You do not have to take Eater's word, or mine. Rougarou at 2844 Welton. Peach Crease Club at 4180 Wynkoop. Go order the chicken on a stick and a fattoush martini and decide for yourself. Just get to the 12-seat bar early. I am telling you that as a friend.

Home·Our Listings·News·About·Privacy·Terms