Revolutionizing · Modernizing · Simplifying
Business

How a $79,000 Scramble Saved the Nob Hill Inn on Colfax

The Nob Hill Inn at 420 E. Colfax reopened Nov. 21 after a near-death closure, a $79,000 community fundraiser, and BRT construction that nearly finished it.
By Derek Schulze · November 22, 2026
How a $79,000 Scramble Saved the Nob Hill Inn on Colfax

Christy Simonsen was standing in the middle of the Nob Hill Inn when she had what she calls a serious meltdown. And honestly, who could blame her.

Photo: westword.com
Photo: westword.com

Her longtime boss John Plessinger had just handed her everything. The liquor license, which is one of the oldest in Denver. The name. The whole business. He put it all in her lap in late August 2026 and retired, and she went from head bartender to owner of a century-old dive bar on East Colfax basically overnight.

Then it almost all disappeared.

Photo: denver7.com
Photo: denver7.com

The bar that would not die

Let me back up, because the Nob Hill Inn at 420 E. Colfax Ave. has been dodging the grave for a long time.

This place has poured drinks for roughly a century. Some sources say it has been at the Colfax address since 1954. Others pegged it at 83 years old back in 2020, which would put the opening around 1937. Either way, we are talking about a Denver institution that predates almost everything around it.

Plessinger inherited it from his father in 1969. His dad had been running it since the 1940s. So this was a family bar for decades before Christy, a Denver-born woman with about 15 years behind this exact bar, took the keys.

And the thing is, the Nob has survived stuff that would flatten a normal business. It made it through the 2020 COVID closure. It survived a 2023 fire on the block that damaged neighboring Duman's Custom Tailor. It survived the 2023 death of Bart Case, the beloved longtime bartender, whose full name was Bartley Case and who a lot of regulars still talk about.

Most places do not come back from one of those hits. The Nob kept coming back.

"Under-construction stationon Colfax Avenue in Denver" by Laztwin is marked with CC0 1.0. To view the terms, visit https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/deed.en/.
"Under-construction stationon Colfax Avenue in Denver" by Laztwin is marked with CC0 1.0. To view the terms, visit https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/deed.en/.

Then Colfax dug itself up

Here is the part people miss about the near-closure.

It was not one dramatic thing. It was construction. The ongoing Bus Rapid Transit work on Colfax Avenue cut straight into the bar's business, and staff told Denver7 that the BRT disruption could be the thing that finally closed the Nob for good. You have seen the Colfax corridor lately. Torn up, detoured, a mess to get to. For a neighborhood bar that runs on people wandering in, that is a slow bleed.

By September 2026 the math got brutal. The Nob needed to raise roughly $79,000 by Sept. 30 or close permanently. That money covered a loan payoff plus urgent repairs. A woman named Brittani Trujillo organized a GoFundMe on Christy's behalf, and the Denver bar community did what it does.

The money came in. And it went to real, unglamorous things. Lawyer fees for lease and loan negotiation. Repairs to the bar floor. A replacement beer cooler, because you cannot run a dive without cold beer. That is where a bar lives or dies.

That fundraiser bought a reprieve. And the reprieve turned into a reopening.

The grand reopening

The weekend of Nov. 21, 2026, the Nob Hill Inn reopened following a renovation, and threw a grand reopening party to mark it. Westword called it, and I think this is exactly right, "one of Denver's last remaining OG dive bars," reopened "following a much-needed renovation effort."

Last remaining. Sit with that for a second.

Frank Locantore, who runs the Colfax Business Improvement District as executive director, has described affordable neighborhood dive bars like this one as "a dying breed." He is not wrong. The cheap, unpretentious corner bar where anybody can afford a drink is vanishing off Colfax, and every time one closes it does not come back as another one. It comes back as something more expensive, or it comes back as nothing.

Why this one matters

What makes the Nob worth saving is not the building. It is who is inside it.

Christy has said the crowd runs from 95-year-olds to 21-year-olds, drinking side by side at the same bar. That does not happen anywhere else. Your trendy cocktail spot does not have a 95-year-old regular. The Nob does.

And bartender Gabriel Ortega keeps a long-running rumor alive that Bob Dylan once wandered in and sat in a booth. Is it true? No idea. But that is the kind of story a real dive collects over a hundred years. The expensive new places have a brand story written by a consultant. The Nob has a Dylan rumor passed bartender to bartender.

The real estate read

Quick note from the Symbio Homes side of my brain, because this is where it ties together.

When people talk about Colfax real estate and the BRT line, they talk about it like pure upside. Transit, density, investment, new builds. And sure, long term that corridor is going to look very different. But the Nob Hill Inn is the live example of the cost that nobody prices in. The same construction that is supposed to raise values nearly killed a hundred-year-old business before the upgrade even finished. The character that makes a block worth living near is exactly the stuff that gets squeezed out first.

So the Nob survived. For now. On lawyer fees, a new cooler, a floor repair, and about 79 grand from people who did not want to lose it.

Go have a drink there. That is how you actually keep a place like this open.

420 E. Colfax Ave. Bring cash, bring a friend who is 95, and sit in the Dylan booth.

Home·Our Listings·News·About·Privacy·Terms